A Finals
| Season | Champion | Runner-Up |
| 2014 Inaugural | DeadFlip | Hooligans |
| 2014 Fall | Hooligans | DeadFlip |
| 2015 Spring | Hooligans | DeadFlip |
| 2015 Fall | Pinsane Clown Posse | Scoop Shootin’ Boogie |
| 2016 Spring | Pinsane Clown Posse | Hooligans |
| 2016 Fall | Hooligans | Tilt Chamberlain |
| 2017 Spring | Hooligans | |
| 2017 Fall | Hooligans | Tilty As Charged |
| 2018 Spring | Hooligans | Extra Ballsy |
| 2018 Fall | Hooligans | Extra Ballsy |
| 2019 Spring | Hooligans | Pinsane Clown Posse |
| 2019 Fall | Hooligans | Pinsane Clown Posse |
| 2021 Fall | Pinsane Clown Posse | Extra Ballsy |
| 2022 Spring | Hooligans | Pinsane Clown Posse |
| 2022 Fall | Pinsane Clown Posse | Extra Ballsy |
| 2023 Spring | Pinsane Clown Posse | Hooligans |
| 2023 Fall | Extra Ballsy | The Ones Who Knock |
| 2024 Spring | The Ones Who Knock | Loop Garoo |
| 2024 Fall | Extra Ballsy | The Ones Who Knock |
| 2025 Spring | Extra Ballsy | The Ones Who Knock |
B-Finals
| Season | Champion | Runner-Up |
| 2021 Fall | Tilt Chamberlain | Pin Pals |
| 2022 Spring | Tilt Chamberlain | Loop Garoo |
| 2022 Fall | The Geek Knights | Loop Garoo |
| 2023 Spring | Out of Service When Lit | The Solenoids |
| 2023 Fall | Greg’s Good Guys | Out of Service When Lit |
| 2024 Spring | Greg’s Good Guys | Scoop Shootin’ Boogie |
| 2024 Fall | The Geek Knights | New Kids On The Knock |
| 2025 Spring | Much Ado About Nudging | The Geek Knights |
Regular Season Champions
| Season | Champion |
| 2014 Inaugural | Deadflip |
| 2014 Fall | Deadflip |
| 2015 Spring | Hooligans |
| 2015 Fall | Hooligans |
| 2016 Spring | Pinsane Clown Posse |
| 2016 Fall | The Geek Knights |
| 2017 Spring | Scoop Shootin’ Boogie |
| 2017 Fall | Hooligans |
| 2018 Spring | Hooligans |
| 2018 Fall | Extra Ballsy |
| 2019 Spring | Hooligans |
| 2019 Fall | Pinsane Clown Posse |
| 2021 Fall | Pinsane Clown Posse |
| 2022 Spring | Hooligans/Tilty As Charged |
| 2022 Fall | Greg’s Good Guys |
| 2023 Spring | Hooligans |
| 2023 Fall | The Ones Who Knock |
| 2024 Spring | Out of Service When Lit |
| 2024 Fall | Pinsane Clown Posse |
| 2025 Spring | Extra Ballsy |